The Effectiveness of Cancel Culture
Cancel culture is the essence of mob mentality. It's power by numbers. Finding something that everyone can agree on can be difficult unless that thing is hate. Hate is one of the rare emotions that clouds rational thinking and empowers the urge to be reckless. It’s carnal anger. And what is better than feeling anger alone? Feeling anger with thousands. When your emotions are felt by others as well, it’s validating. You don’t second guess yourself. In fact, you're encouraged to feel deeper and harder. Plus, we’re social creatures so wanting to be a part of a group is human nature. Participating in cancel culture gives a way to vent out anger. It’s also a tool to turn people’s anger into action. It’s making their anger something that can’t be ignored. So that leads to an interesting question. How effective is cancel culture?
In an article by the University of Central Florida, a professor of Sociology named Amanda Koontz stated “Public shaming is a long-standing public ritual that helped to uphold social bonds and make sure people within communities were equal and understood the norms, and to ensure no one got too high and mighty” (Dudenhoefer 2020). Nowadays we have justice systems to do that. We have trials, judges, and juries to determine someone's guilt and how intense their punishment must be. However, the faith in these systems to hand out justice has been decreasing, making the public feel that they must take it into their own hands.
Due to how often someone is being canceled, a type of script has developed for how to apologize for whatever transgression has occurred. This has led to people “making either empty apologies or excuses without understanding the full magnitude of their actions” (Celentano 2021). That being said, it doesn’t mean their apology gets them out of consequences. People have lost jobs and been publicly shunned due to cancel culture. So I guess what first needs to be addressed is the goal of “canceling” someone. Is it to get a genuine apology or to force a consequence? Maybe both. If the goal is to get an apology, it seems that cancel culture is quite ineffective. If the purpose is to force a consequence on the individual, then it seems to work perfectly. But as a parent would punish a child, the true goal is to change behavior. That may be an impossible question to answer, and one I will go on trying to tackle in future posts. Does cancel culture change behavior?
Celentano, D. (2021, April 20). Cancel Culture: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. The Science Survey. https://thesciencesurvey.com/editorial/2021/04/20/cancel-culture-the-good-the-bad-and-the-ugly/
Is Cancel Culture Effective? How Public Shaming Has Changed. (2020, October 20). Pegasus Magazine.
https://www.ucf.edu/pegasus/is-cancel-culture-effective/
Cancel culture had become more prevalent since the upcoming of the use social media. Someone could literally do one thing , and they are immediately cancelled, it doesn't be by 1 person it goes from thousands maybe even millions. For the people that use social media as a source of income, and are influences these can be very damaging to their life style. The companies that they may be working with may withdraw their contracts just to keep there consumers happy and to not loss business. As cancel culture relates to us, you can see that it is very effective to a certain extent . For example Jeffery Star was cancelled maybe 5 years ago and since then you don't hear much about him and his youtube videos aren't trending, that doesn't mean he isn't making money or losing it, but it shows much effective cancel culture can be and is. Mentally this may have effected is outlook on social media and could have made him go out and find a way to get another source of economy.
ReplyDelete